HomeAbout
0 Frank's Reel Reviews 0
0 submit a review
Movie Details | Reel Rating | Movie Review | DVD Information | Message Forum
0
0

See more reviews in the Movie Review Archives

A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
W
X
Y
Z





Winged MigrationWinged Migration (2001)
Rated: G for General Audiences.
Runtime: 98 mins.
Director: Jacques Perrin
Writer: Stéphane Durand; Jacques Perrin
Tagline: An Incredible Vision of nature From a new Perspective.
Cast: JacquesPerrin....
complete cast
Genre: Documentary/Family
Most memorable quote:
The Arctic Tern flies 12,500 miles from the Arctic to the Antarctic.



Reel Rating

Julia Roberts factor: 5/5
Macho factor: 4/5
Babysitter factor: 5/5
Get Lucky factor: 3/5
In-law factor: 5/5
Of Mice and Men factor 2/5
Wrap-up factor 0/5
Se7en factor 0/5
Reel rating: 4/5
Reel commentary: I might have been more impressed if Perrin and Crew had somehow been able to film "wild" birds at such close quarters rather than imprinted "pets"...but the film's message can't be denied. Bird migration is a powerful and life-assuring inspiration that somehow belittles that fact that my car wouldn't start this morning.........full review


Awards: 2003 Academy Award Nomination for Best Documentary.

Movie Review

by Frank Wilkins

The moment I saw the first bird flying alongside the camera, I knew something wasn't as promised. The Canada Goose was within my arm's reach, its tiniest of downy feathers visible, ruffling in the current, its eyes were perceptibly gazing back at me. That a film crew could get so close to a flock of wild geese was beyond my belief. But as Winged Migration progressed and my amazement at its spectacular beauty failed to lessen, it became clear to me that no matter what secret techniques were deployed in filming this majestic wonder, the film's impact on me would never falter.

Filmmaker Jacques Perrin mentions in the opening credits of Winged Migration that no special effects were used in filming this movie. While that is true, he fails to mention that the birds used in the filming of this picture are in effect trained actors, and that many of the film's scenes were staged for dramatic impact. I guess that means Winged Migration is not a documentary, but whatever it is, its majesty and ornithological significance can't be denied. What points it loses for its contrivances and staged scenes, it more than makes up for with its scientific relevance. I now retain a healthy respect for the fragility of nature.

Through the process of imprinting, Perrin was able to embed his more than 450 associates - from cinematographers to student veterinarians - into the migratory formations of several species of birds as they made their semi-annual trek of hundreds or even thousands of miles across the globe. Imprinting is the process by which a newborn or very young bird establishes a behavior pattern of recognition and attraction to a human that is identified as the parent. Perrin's team filmed the birds using boats, ultra-light aircraft, powered-parachutes and robotic camera arms. What results is stunning footage of birds flying alongside the Eiffel Tower; high over the Great Wall of China; above a falling glacier wall; and down the Hudson River with the Manhattan skyline in the background. Especially moving was seeing the twin towers of the World Trade Center still intact. The segment was shot in 1999.

As the film progresses we begin to feel a deep and personal affection for the winged creatures. We recognize the characteristics of individual birds and we genuinely cringe at the loss of several birds to hunters' shotgun blasts, factory oil spills and attacks by predators. As staged as these scenes are, the fact remains that these are real-life perils faced by our flighted friends on a daily basis.

Despite its sweeping drama, several problems plague the film throughout. The continuity of the project seems to be very disjointed. While the film is broken down into cinematic chapters of sorts, the flow doesn't feel natural. Each "chapter" features a different species of bird, but we jump around the world in such dramatic leaps that I found myself wanting to stay in a particular region of the world a bit longer. Just when I was getting interested in watching the rock-hopper penguins of Antarctica, we jump to a hyacinth macaw in the rain forest of the Amazon.

I might have been more impressed if Perrin and Crew had somehow been able to film "wild" birds at such close quarters rather than imprinted "pets". And perhaps I wouldn't have experienced a bit of a letdown if the most emotionally effective scenes weren't staged. But the film's message can't be denied. Bird migration is a powerful and life-assuring inspiration that somehow belittles that fact that my car wouldn't start this morning. What we humans perceive as cute and a thing of beauty, a bird sees as a means of survival.

Frank Wilkins

Read or post comments about this film on the
Winged Migration Discussion Forum


return to top


DVD Information

Screen formats: Widescreen Anamorphic 1.85:1

Subtitles: English, Spanish, Portuguese, Hindi; Closed Captioned

Language and Sound: English: Dolby Digital 5.1

Other Features: Color; interactive menus; scene access; making-of featurette; director's commentary; music featurette; photo gallery (with commentary); filmmaker interviews; trailers.

  • Scenes - Scene access with 24 chapters. Each chapter features a different species of bird or a different region of the globe. Chapters: 1-Start; 2-Greylag Goose; 3-Eurasion Crane; 4-White Stork; 5-Barnacle Goose; 6-Whooper Swan; 7-Barheaded Goose; 8-Red Crowned Crane; 9-Bald Eagle; 10-Canada Goose; 11-Swan Goose; 12-Clark's Grebe; 13-Sandhill Crane; 14-Greater Sage Grouse; 15-Common Murre; 16-Northern Gannet; 17-Arctic Tern; 18-Red Breasted Goose; 19-Waders; 20-African White Pelican; 21-The Amazon; 22-Albatross
  • Bonus Materials -
    • Featurettes:
      • "Making-Of" featurette: 50 minute short that goes behind the scenes in revealing how this extraordinary film was made. Discusses the process of "imprinting" and shows great additional footage of the various crafts that were used to film the stunning scenes.
      • Creating the Music Featurette: 15-minute discussion with Perrin and Bruno Coulais as the cover the process from concept to completion of creating the film's score.
    • Commentary:
      • Full length Director's Commentary - with Jacques Perrin discussing the concept of the project and the difficulties his crew encountered. Perrin also displays his vast knowledge of the species of birds featured in the film.
      • Photo Gallery: With Filmmaker Commentary about all of the different species featured in the movie.
    • Interviews:
      • In-depth Filmmaker interviews: 2 interviews that total 25 minutes in length.
        • About the Film features more discussion with Perrin and co-director Michel Debats about the creative process.
        • Further Insights contains some nice personal recollections about some particular moments of the film and also includes some additional footage.
    • Trailer:
      • Original Theatrical Trailer
      • Featuring Cirque de Soliel: Varekai

    Combined Grade
    Movie
    DVD
    4/5
    3/5

    Buy
    "Winged Migration" Now:
    In Association with Amazon.com

    Still image capture of the animated menu screen

Complete Cast

Jacques Perrin......... Narrator

return to top




0
0
©2002, Frank's Reel Reviews. All rights reserved.